Paprika is a standard shaker available in Papa's Nachoria/HD/To Go!. It is unlocked with Marco (Desktop) or Dante (HD) when the player reaches Rank 15. The player will earn the "Curry Cover" badge when 30 orders are served using this shaker.
Paprika is a holiday-exclusive seasoning available during Cinco de Mayo in Papa's Meateria. It is unlocked on Rank 24.
Paprika is a standard popcorn chicken topping available to customers in Papa's Bubble Tea Mia! Deluxe. The popcorn chicken topping is unlocked with Belladonna when the player reaches Rank 121.